Skip to content
Customer ServiceNew York proposes rule giving customers stuck with AI bots the right to a human agent
Customer ServiceNews1 min read

New York proposes rule giving customers stuck with AI bots the right to a human agent

A proposal from the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection would treat automated customer service that fails to solve problems as a deceptive trade practice and impose penalties starting at $525 on violators.

Only 15% get a seamless handoff — New York proposes a rule giving customers stuck with an AI bot the right to reach a human agent. A wire cut in two; the severed ends have drawn close but do not touch.
AI-generated image

What's happening

According to Customer Experience Magazine, New York City has proposed a rule requiring businesses to offer customers easy access to a human agent when automated systems fail to resolve an issue. The city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection published the rule, which would treat inadequate automated service as a deceptive and unconscionable trade practice. If the rule takes effect, violators will owe restitution plus civil penalties starting at $525.

Whose desk it lands on

The executive responsible for customer experience. How many steps does it take a customer to reach a human agent when the bot cannot help?

Our view

The CX Brief's interpretation, not a claim made by the source.

The rule moves the real test of customer service from the bot itself to where the bot leaves off: the handoff to a human. According to Twilio's consumer research, only 15% of customers experience a seamless handoff from AI to an agent, and the proposed requirement would apply at exactly that point.

Newsletter coming soon

An English edition of The CX Brief newsletter is on its way. We are not taking sign-ups yet.

Learn more